Research Blog #2: Preliminary Research

Where things stand right now

After some consideration I decided to go with my first research proposal, since it is more personal to me and has a lot more avenues to pursue. I am sure the history of college will remain relevant to the discussion of college gap years and dropping out regardless.

I have also considered narrowing my research topic to exclude college transfers. I think all three topics (gap years, dropping out, transferring) are somewhat interconnected and can bring about an interesting synthesis of ideas, but I am worried I'm taking too broad of an approach that can leave all three topics underdeveloped in the final research paper.

Researching articles

Using just some general keywords like "dropping out," "transferring college," and "gap year," I was able to find a lot of useful information for my research paper. A lot of the articles I saw related to students taking gap years or even dropping out due to COVID-19, for both financial and personal reasons. Like I suspected, a lot of students have testified to taking a gap year because of their complaints against the structure of online classes. I also came across an interesting article detailing the most common reasons why students take gap years or drop out, which could be a good starting point for my own paper. An important point one college adviser makes is how college gap years can be an enriching experience, but if you're taking a gap year just to work at a low-income job, you're at a much higher risk of dropping out altogether.

For the transfer pathway, I found a very comprehensive article examining all the pitfalls of why many college transfers don't work out. Out of the three topics I'm pursuing, I had the least amount of prior knowledge going into this one, so it was fortunate that I found this. There were three major pitfalls to college transferring I gleaned from this reading:

  1. Falling behind in credits
  2. Lack of advising and direction towards important college resources
  3. Isolation from college culture
These varied issues surrounding college transfers somewhat renewed my interest in this topic, so I may end up sticking with it after all.

The scholarly articles I skimmed through provided some more in-depth information to supplement what I already learned in the normal articles. There were a few articles I found that provided more substantial evidence of how financial status directly contributes to college retention rates, which I definitely plan to mine for information in the future. Another study I found provided a comparative analysis between different majors to determine the early-warning predictors of a student at risk of dropping out. The research conducted in this paper uses advanced prediction models such as machine learning to deduce their results, and I hope to use some of their findings in my own essay.

New ideas and resources

 From the brief research I conducted on my topic, it seems that this area of study is examined mostly under an economic lens. The dominating reason people seem to take a gap year, drop out, or transfer colleges is because of financial concerns, so it will probably be a focal point for my own essay. Going down this route will also let me explore how college promotes social stratification by forcing less affluent students to take less favorable pathways.

A potential resource I stumbled upon in my research was a hotline to a "gap-year specialist." Speaking to a specialist or even just an adviser at Rutgers could also be a good jumping off point for my research paper. Another resource I found was advice given to students to dissuade them from dropping out. It seems relevant to me that there are few resources out there for what to do if you decide to drop out, but a lot of information on why you shouldn't. The website lists offices you can contact and resources you can seek out, which can help position myself to better understanding the psychology of why students seek such an extreme option.

Potential complications?

Of course, this topic can't only be viewed from an economic lens. Students often take gap years to travel abroad or learn new skills, and some of the most successful people in the world started their fortunes after dropping out of college. This isn't anything surprising, but it does complicate the general thesis I am trying to construct somewhat.

Another point of contention I have is about the topic of dropping out. Aside from a few exceptional cases, dropping out is commonly seen as a step towards downward mobility, leaving you with no degree and a lot of debt. I want to seek out advice from professionals about the best path to seek out after dropping out of college, assuming you don't have some million dollar business venture with the parental support to fund it.

Links:

Articles:

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-07/u-s-college-students-on-covid-gap-years-are-taking-big-financial-risks

https://www.the74million.org/article/thats-not-a-gap-year-thats-just-not-going-to-college-covid-19-erodes-equity-gains-of-first-generation-college-goers/ 

https://www.yearon.com/blog/5-reasons-students-drop-out-of-college-and-how-to-prepare-yourself-for-them

 Scholarly Articles:

Running out of STEM: a comparative study across STEM majors of college students at-risk of dropping out early 

Gender, Debt, and Dropping Out of College

Student Loans, Financial Stress, and College Student Retention 

Resources:

Gap Year Specialist Hotline: 1 (510) 985-9711

More information and advising about gap years: https://www.gapyearassociation.org/

Preventing student drop-outs: https://www.accreditedschoolsonline.org/resources/preventing-students-dropping-out/ 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Literature Review #3: Academically adrift: limited learning on college campuses

Image
  Originally published in 2011 Citation: Arum, Richard, and Josipa Roksa. Academically Adrift : Limited Learning on College Campuses . University of Chicago Press, 2011. Summary:  This book documents a longitudinal study conducted to determine how much college students' critical thinking skills improved from when they first entered college to the end of their sophomore year. Growth in critical thinking was determined using the Collegiate Learning Assessment (CLA), which was considered one of the most sophisticated and well-developed performance evaluators at the time. The researchers, Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa, are both well-respected sociologists who specialize in education and how it affects social stratification. The study ultimately concluded that students generally showed very little signs of growth in critical thinking and writing skills during this time period, improving their skills, on average "by only 0.18 standard deviation" (35). What makes these re...
Read more

Research Blog #4: Research Proposal

  (This proposal is unchanged from the original draft, apologies for publishing this late) Sean Park Professor Michael Goeller Research in Disciplines: College! 19 February 2021 Research Proposal 1) Working Title Gap Years and Dropping Out: How the COVID-19 Pandemic Exacerbates Anxieties About Higher Education, Especially Among Lower Income Families 2) Topic Description One of the many side effects that came with the onset of the recent pandemic was the drastic drop in student enrollment in higher education. The early months of the stay-at-home orders were characterized by schools scrambling to transition to online learning, with varying degrees of success based on the preexisting infrastructure they had. Anxieties about the pandemic and changes to schools during this time have prompted many students to take a gap year or drop out entirely to seek out more meaningful experiences or careers. An article from the Wall Street Journal noted how many students took a leave...
Read more

Initial Topic Ideas

Image
Mind the gap. The first two weeks of class have given me a lot of ideas for interesting topics to write about, but for right now I have two specific ideas I have been developing in my head. Topic 1: Gap Years, Dropping Out, and Transferring This is a topic I have a personal investment in, since I have experienced or have had people close to me experience these dramatic shifts in their academic trajectory within the past few years. I would like to explore the statistics for how many students go through with these options, for what reasons, and how it has affected their prospects afterwards. I expect this topic to intersect with topics of mental health and the anxiety that comes with going to college, which I intend to fully analyze. Ultimately, I want to answer the following questions: Why do students go down these paths, if they aren't forced to? How does going down these paths affect someone's future prospects and well-being? When would it be a good time to think about these o...
Read more